Skip to main content

Europe Fighting it Out in the Courts over Air Pollution

It has been a long time coming, but today the European Commission referred 7 member states - France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Luxembourg, Romania, and the United Kingdom - to the Court of Justice for violations of air pollution limits on NO2 and PM10.  In the past the commission has been gun shy when it came to enforcing air quality legislation, letting repeated violations slide over the past decade.  However they have recently ramped up their actions, obtaining a favourable ECJ judgement against Bulgaria last year, and against Poland earlier this year.  As I discussed recently, Poland have the worst air quality in Europe by many measures, but have recently initiated a major program to improve heating and cut air pollution.  It is not unreasonable to connect this action to pressure from the European Commission, and hopefully today's events will see similar efforts elsewhere in the EU.  It should however be noted that the Czech Republic, Slovakia, and Spain appear to have dodged a bullet, after earlier threats to include them in this enforcement action.

At the same time as this plays out, Brussels, Madrid, and Paris are pushing back at the European Commission by challenging what they interpret as lax new vehicle emissions standards.  As the world moves to on-road emissions testing in the wake of the dieslgate defeat device scandal, I predict we are going to see more wrestling like this between stakeholders on both sides trying to get standards that suit their interests.  In the case of automakers, that means trying to get more pollutants into the air while they can.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Methyl Bromide Leaves Residents Fuming

The Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer has proven to be a resounding environmental success, halting and then reversing the depletion of stratospheric ozone caused by man-made halogenated compounds.  Although global efforts initially focused on long-lived chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), as their atmospheric levels have begun to decline it is emerging that "short-lived" ozone depleting substances with atmospheric lifetimes of months to years are playing an increasingly significant role, and they are also proving more of a challenge to eradicate.
The atmospheric chemistry of short lived ozone depleting substances is an area of research I'm currently working on, so I was intrigued to see one of these compounds - methyl bromide - in the news this week.  A proposal to build a large methyl bromide fumigation facility to treat logs in the North Carolina town of Delco has been met with anger from locals, who are concerned about potential health and environm…

New Zealand's Toxic Methyl Bromide Problem

Concerns are mounting in New Zealand around the continued use of methyl bromide for fumigation.  Methyl bromide is a highly effective fumigant, but it is also depletes the ozone layer and is harmful to human health.  Under the Montreal Protocol for the regulation of ozone depleting substances, use of methyl bromide is banned for all but a few exempt quarantine purposes. This ban has seen measured atmospheric levels of this substance drop from about 10 to 8 parts per trillion. In New Zealand, however, methyl bromide usage is soaring, with a 2020 deadline to eliminate methyl bromide emissions looming.

One of the biggest exemptions for methyl bromide use is in fumigating logs for export. China and India are the main destinations and both prefer methyl bromide treatment as a bio-security measure. New Zealand is a significant exporter of logs to China and India, and in recent years has grown to become one of the biggest users of methyl bromide worldwide. The NZ government have a 2020 deadl…

Fake Plastic Tree Refuses to Die

Just like that cheap plastic Christmas tree that mum trots out every year, stories about the scientifically questionable CityTree refuse to die.  This press release masquerading as news has been rehashed and reprinted with little scientific analysis by Wired, Forbes, Dezeen, CNN - and - so -  many - others that it made me throw up in my mouth a little and I had to stop googling it.

As I wrote the other day, these CityTrees make almost impossible claims to purify air of nearly every pollutant, all the way from particulate matter down to carbon dioxide.  This last one is the most challenging to accept, as it has been reported that each fake plastic tree "has the air purifying power of 275 normal trees". That is a direct quote from once-respected newspaper The Independent. Yes, that The Independent.

It is claimed that each one of these devices removes 240,000 kg of carbon dioxide from the air every year, equivalent to a small forest.  This means, however, that about one tonne (o…